We may earn an affiliate commission when you buy via links on our site. Learn more.

We know you can find your own way to a Hickory Farms or Harry & David cheese gift basket. We want to expand your shopping choices. If you are buying a cheese gift, or wanting to treat yourself, please consider the artisan cheese makers and selected cheesemongers below. The selection and quality of American and international cheeses will delight you!

Saxelby Cheese, American Farmstead Cheese, New York

appalachian cheese

Appalachian Cheese

Havarti Cheese

Havarti Farmstead Cheese

Saxelby Cheese Shop in New York City, founded by Anne Saxeleby and Renoit Breal, specializes in American farmstead and artisan cheese sought after by top chefs and cheese lovers everywhere. Their website allows you to curate your own cheese gift assortment cheese-by-cheese (you’re going to get mesmerized by the amazing choices) so you can mix your buttery bries and tangy blues, or you can jump straight to their curated cheese gift sets that include crackers and condiments designed to delight!

 

Order Cheese Gifts Online at Saxelby Cheese

Pricing: Often as good or better than prices at your local cheesemonger

Shipping: FedEx Ground/Home Delivery Shipments over $100 ship FREE. Orders under $100 ship for a flat rate of $10.

Send a Cheese Gift Basket! Order Cheese Gifts Online at Saxelby Cheese

Murray’s Cheese, New York

Brie Cheese with Honey

A Buttery Brie drizzled with honey

Aged Gouda Cheese

Aged Gouda Cheese

Where Saxelby Cheese features American cheeses, Murray’s Cheese buyers travel regularly in Europe and across the US in search of the new and great artisan cheeses being produced from California to Vermont, and from Athens to Wales. Choose from nutty gouda cheese and mushroomy bries, but trust us, that’s just the warm up.

Not only does Murray’s have an amazing and ever evolving selection of international cheeses, but their website is beautifully designed to help you discover mouth-watering cheese and cheese combinations–even for those who rarely stray beyond buying American, mozzarella, or Cheddar.

Choose individual cheeses (there’s no way you’ll only choose one), or make a quick selection from the pre-matched selections of cheese such as the Taste of Italy sampler, the Best of France selection, or the Cheeses of the World sampler. Maybe add some options from their Charcuterie selections, or other specialty foods Murray’s offers (crackers, jams, nuts, etc.), and there is no doubt your gift will be remembered.

 

Mail Order Cheese Gifts Online at Murray’s Cheese

Pricing: Individual cheeses start at $10 but a great cheese gift selection is going to run $50+

Shipping: 1-day, 2-day and Ground Shipping available

Send a Cheese Gift! Order cheese gift baskets online at Murray’s Cheese

Cowgirl Creamery, Artisanal Organic Cheese Gifts

Organic Cheese Gifts

Organic Artisan Cheese Selection from Cowgirl Creamery

Rainbow Layer Cake to Order Online

Artisan Cheese and Meat Gift Platter

Cowgirl Creamery in California, partners with local dairies in Marin and Sonoma counties to source organic, pasture-based, cow’s milk for every cheese they craft. If you have enjoyed any of their cheeses available at Whole Foods and other top cheesemongers, you know the pleasure of their amazing cheeses. We buy the organic triple cream Red Hawk on the regular. Their website is gorgeous and informative. Their cheese gift selection is flawless. Send a cheese gift from Cowgirl Creamery and just sit back and expect to be buried in appreciative “thank yous.” You’ve just given a gift in the very best taste.

Mail Order Cheese Gift Baskets from Cowgirl Creamery

Pricing: Cheese gifts are $70+ and worth every delicious cent

Shipping: FedEx Overnight Monday through Thursday

Send a Cheese Gift Basket! Order cheese gifts online at Cowgirl Creamery

Pt. Reyes Farmstead Cheese, California

Complete Cheese Gift Sets

Cheese Gifts: Toma with Truffles

Toma Cheese with Black Truffles

Pt. Reyes Farmstead Cheese Company, like other dairies that lovingly produce world-class cheese, could have been one of the many businesses that succumbed to the Covid crisis. With restaurants closed, food supply chains stymied, cheese demand dropped precipitously. This family-run dairy, famous for their sustainable farming practices, happy cows and amazing cheese, faced a once-in-a-hundred years business crisis. Every decision they made mattered to their cows, their employees, and, yes, to you if their fine cheeses stopped production, or never made it to market.

They are weathering the storm and are emerging both stronger and smarter, and you’re the beneficiary. You can shop their cheese selections either individually, but we encourage you to explore their beautifully chosen and priced gift packs. Consider booking one of their Zoom tastings—we are! It’s the perfect gift experience to share with family near and far.

Mail Order Cheese Gifts Online at Pt. Reyes Cheese Company

Pricing: $40.00+

Shipping: $10 flat rate overnight shipping anywhere in the contiguous United States. A bargain!

Corporate orders: Yes

Let’s shop cheese gifts! Pt. Reyes Farmstead Cheese Company.