We may earn an affiliate commission when you buy via links on our site. Learn more.
Milk Bar, NY, LA, DC
Milk Bar was one of the first to feature “naked” layer cakes—cakes that have little or no icing around their sides to better showcase the deliciousness that lies within. The result is visually stunning and hard to resist. Milk Bar cakes come in 6-inch & 10-inch sizes (gluten-free versions are available), and they always feature a seasonal or holiday-inspired cake that never fails to delight. This is the cool big sister of traditional layer cakes, that will leave a delicious impression.
Mail Order Cakes Online at Milk Bar
Pricing: 6-inch and 10-inch round cakes begin at $50.
Shipping: Free shipping on orders $75+
Send a Cake! Order Cake online from Milk Bar
Caroline’s Cakes, South Carolina
Mail Order Cakes Online at Caroline’s Cakes
Pricing: Buy a 9-inch round 7-layer cake for $70.
Shipping: $15 2-day shipping! (An excellent price)
Send a Cake! Order Cake online from Caroline’s Cakes
Over the Rainbow Cakes, Miami, Florida
Somewhere over the rainbow are the most delicious & decadent, out-of-this-world Rainbow Cakes! These jaw-dropping cakes start with four layers of rich Chocolate, scrumptious Golden Butter, or delightfully delectable Red Velvet cake, with a rainbow of beautiful swirls of buttercream frosting in-between each. These sky-high, outrageous cakes are then coated with vanilla frosting and finished with hundreds of — what else? — rainbow sprinkles! These Rainbow Cakes are incredible, edible centerpieces for any party, and they’re shipping nationwide!
Order Cake for Delivery from Over the Rainbow Cakes
Pricing: Buy a 6-inch round 4-layer cake with free shipping for $70.
Shipping: Free Shipping!
Send a Cake! Order a Rainbow Cake for delivery via Goldbelly
We Take the Cake, Ft. Lauderdale, Florida
Another favorite on Oprah’s list, We Take the Cake is an absolute “go to” to send wow-worthy cakes and cupcakes. When I think cake, my first though is the frosting: please, please let me get a slice with the big frosted roses on it. The more elaborate the frosting, the better. Apparently We Take the Cake knows my type and pipes elaborate cupcakes that make my heart swoon. They are also famous for their bundt cakes. The Key Lime Bundt cake (7-inch round, serves 6) is one of Oprah’s favorites.
One thing: Pay attention to the cake sizes. A six-inch cake may look good in photos, but they are pretty small IRL. If you are looking for a larger cake, consider Caroline’s 9-inch cakes above.
Mail Order Cakes Online at We Take the Cake
Pricing: Bundt Cakes begin at $50 with free shipping
Shipping: Free shipping
Send a Cake! Order cakes and cupcakes online from We Take the Cake via Goldbelly.
Daisy Cakes, Pauline, South Carolina
Daisy Cakes, created by Kim Nelson, came to national attention when Kim appeared on Shark Tank. Barbara Corcoran “bit” and invested in Kim’s vision for Daisy Cakes, and has since taken the bakery from sales in the 4 figures a month to sales of 6 figures per month. That’s a lot of cake (and happy customers)!
Kim bakes her cakes from recipes passed down to her from her great aunt Daisy and her grandmother who themselves were baking from recipes handed down for generations. Kim says her cakes are made from all-natural ingredients and lots of “Southern love.”
Current offerings include: Red Velvet cake, Chocolate Layer Cake, Lemon, Coconut, and their best-selling no-nuts-added Carrot Cake which is made with a pound of carrots, golden raisins and real cream cheese frosting.
The cakes are 8 1/2 inches round and 4 inches high. They are said to serve 16 – 20 people. Uh, Ms. Daisy has never been to my house. This size cake may feed 16 genteel ladies at a baby shower, but in my house, I’d estimate it would top out at 8 servings due to the generous proportions that my family thinks is “normal.” Not me of course! Oh, just a sliver for me…and please don’t notice when my sliver is gone that my fork is headed to your plate.
Let’s Go Shopping
Pricing: $59.95+ Shipping
Shipping: Items are shipped frozen via FedEx.
Corporate orders: Yes
Location: Pauline, South Carolina
Take me there! Daisy Cakes via Goldbelly.
Cakes from Red Truck Bakery, Virginia
We have enjoyed and sent nearly every one of Red Truck Bakery’s cakes: Alma Hackney’s Rum Cake, the Almond Cake with Amaretto (so moist, so good), the Triple Chocolate Cake (still getting compliments), the Shenandoah Apple Cake (deep sigh of joy). Also, these cakes are full-sized, which we appreciate.
A beloved rural bakery in Virginia, Red Truck Bakery is located in a renovated 1921 Esso filling station at Courthouse Square in Old Town Warrenton, Virginia. It’s a magnet for folks who are happy to drive for miles to enjoy their cakes, pies, and coffee.
The Washington Post writes: On a typical day, county judges, fox hunters and maybe actor Robert Duvall will be sipping Red Truck coffee at the 12-foot table salvaged from a 19th-century Virginia barn.
Mail Order Cakes Online at Red Truck Bakery
Pricing: 9-inch Bundt style cakes begin at $30.
Send a Cake! Order cakes online at Red Truck Bakery via Goldbelly.