The Best Mail Order Pies Online!
Yes, you can have pie delivered from the best bakeries in the country. Whether it’s Apple Pie from New York, Cherry Pie from Michigan, Blueberry Pies from Maine, or award-winning Pecan Pies from the South, we’ve rounded up the critics’ favorite pies for you. Let’s shop pies!
Pie Delivery! The best mail order pies delivered to your door!
We may earn an affiliate commission when you buy via links on our site. Learn more.
Little Pie Company, New York
The Little Pie Company, a side business started by Broadway actor Arnold Wilkerson in 1985, became a hit in New York and beyond. Praised by Rachel Ray, Oprah Magazine, Bon Apetit Magazine and many, many more, these made-from-scratch pies will satisfy the pie-loving fanatic in you. Consider the “Little Pie Sampler” which includes four mini-pies, one for every taste. Our only regret? They can’t send their banana coconut cream pie. Next time you’re in New York, call me. I’ll meet you and we’ll have a slice.
Pie Delivery from the Little Pie Company
Shipping: Delivery included
My Sugar Pie, Indiana
Milk Bar Crack Pie, New York, New York
From time to time Tosi will add other iconic pies. A favorite is the Waffle Cone Pie. Remember as a kid eating a creamy, crunchy, chocolate-dipped Drumstick? Christina Tosi made a version of it. The crispy waffle cone crust is layered with a nostalgic fudgy brownie bite and cool ice-cream flavored pudding, all dipped in a peanut chocolate shell. Yum!
Award-winning Hand Decorated Pies
Piedaho is a family-owned bakery bringing award-winning pies from the beautiful mountains of Idaho to your table. They use the best local fruit from farms and the highest quality ingredients. Each 10-inch pie is hand made (weighing 3 – 4 pounds) and uniquely decorated to make sure it looks as good as it tastes.
Piedaho’s owner and head baker, Rebecca Bloom graduated from culinary school at the Ecole Ritz Escoffier in Paris. After graduation, she worked in the top kitchens of Los Angeles. Bloom bought her education and first-hand experience back to Idaho to open Piedaho Bakery which has been featured in O Magazine.
Pie Delivery from Piedaho
Shipping: Free Shipping!
Tiny Pie Gift Box, Austin, Texas
Featured on Oprah’s O List, Tiny Pies began to sell its 3 inch, handheld pies at the Barton Creek Farmers Market in Austin, Texas, in 2011. These mini pies were a hit! Made from scratch with locally-sourced ingredients, including their original creation the Texas Two Step — a combination of rich dark chocolate brownie and honest-to-goodness Texas pecan pie layered into a crisp flaky crust. Can’t make up your mind what pie to buy? Buy one of each at Tiny Pies.
Cake Monkey Bakery, Los Angeles, California
LA Weekly named Cake Monkey’s Cherry Almond pie the best pie in Los Angeles. The Cherry Almond Pie is filled with homemade frangipane—a sweet almond-flavored custard—and tart roasted cherries with sugar and Tahitian vanilla beans baked in a flaky, buttery crust that shatters with the touch of your fork. Now imagine their rustic Blueberry Lemon Frangipane pie, sweet and tart with fresh blueberries and fresh lemon followed by the teasing taste of marzipan. You’ll enjoy the flavors at play in every bite.
Pie Delivery from Cake Monkey Bakery
Pricing: A 9-inch pie serves 8 – 10 $79
Shipping: Free shipping
The Fudge Pie Company, Miami, Florida
The Fudge Pie Company also offers delightful seasonal, dense and fudgy versions of pie lovers favorites such as the Key Lime Fudge Pie (tart and dense), the Maple Pecan Fudge Pie, the rich and dense Dulche de Leche Fudge Pie, and we almost hate to tell you about the Cookies and Cream Fudge Pie, because…OMG. When you order, take our advice and order two. Shipping is the same and they arrive packaged so they can be frozen and remain bakery fresh to enjoy whenever a special dessert is exactly what you crave.
Each 9-inch pie weighs a hefty 2 pounds (yup, these pies are rich and dense) and serves 12 – 16.
Red Truck Bakery, Marshall, Virginia
We doubt you were shopping for a peanut pie, but The Red Truck Bakery may be what it takes to change your mind. This Virginia classic is filled with local jumbo peanuts, a little bit of coconut, and a hint of honey. Enjoy it plain or with whipped cream and vanilla ice cream. You’ll enjoy the rich, peanutty goodness in every mouthful.
Pie Delivery from Red TruckBakery
Shipping: 2-day Fed Ex
Order Pie online from Red Truck Bakery via Goldbelly
Three Brothers Bakery, Houston, Texas
Praised as one of the best mail order pies, the Three Brothers Bakery pecan pies also happen to be the most affordable. Their made-from-scratch pecan pie is just $39 with second-day shipping included. Choose from Classic or Chocolate Fudge Pecan Pie. This is an easy holiday gift,
Pie Delivery from Three Brothers Bakery
Pricing: $49 includes second-day delivery!
Shipping: Delivery is included
Buy Pie Online! Order pecan pies online from 3 Brothers Bakery via Goldbelly
Grand Traverse Pie Company, Michigan & Indiana
Grand Traverse Pie Company can be depended on for fantastic classic pies as well as creative re-inventions of everyone’s favorites. The pecan, caramel apple pie? I’ll be back for seconds. Of course, being Michigan-based, they are rightfully famous for their cherry pie. But they don’t stop there. You can buy Cherry/Peach, Cherry/Apple, Cherry/Blueberry. It’s a recipe for decision fatigue so just plan on buying more than you anticipated. And you can. Not only are the pies amazing, they are one of the best values on this list, even with shipping: You can send two 9-inch pies in the same box at no additional shipping.
You can shop their pies via Goldbelly ($54 per pie with free shipping— it’s the same price as on the Grand Traverse store), but if you don’t see exactly what you want, shop the Grand Traverse Pie site directly which offers an even greater selection.
Pie Delivery from Grand Traverse Pie Co.
Pricing: Most pies are around $35
Shipping: $19.99 flat-rate 2-day shipping (you can send two pies in the same box for no additional shipping charges).
Corporate orders: Yes
Location: Michigan and Indiana
Dangerously Delicious Pies, Baltimore, MD
Dangerously Delicious Pies offers both sweet and savory pies, each handmade from scratch with no additives or preservatives. What would otherwise be a Baltimore favorite spot can now be enjoyed anywhere! 10-inch pies begin at $65 which includes shipping. Take time to consider their savory pies. Their steak, mushroom, onion and gruyere pie regularly sells out.
Southern Baked Pie Company, Georgia
Founded in Gainesville, Georgia in 2012, Southern Baked Pie Company was launched by Amanda Wilbanks. Based on treasured family recipes and an all-butter pie dough that melts in your mouth, Amanda and her team of bakers create gourmet sweet and savory pies in a variety of sizes including: whole 10-inch pies, petite 5-inch pies, and bite-size tassies. Not sure which pie to buy? Their signature French Coconut Custard Pie was featured on the Today Show. No matter what you order, you can’t go wrong.
Pie Delivery From Southern Baked Pie Co.
Pricing: Most 10-inch pies are around $40
Shipping: 2-day shipping
Corporate orders: Yes
Buy Pie Online! Southern Baked Pie Company.