Shop the Best Selection of Bagels Online

Let’s start with full disclosure: most of our reviewers live or have lived in New York. We are a contentious, opinionated group that can all agree on one thing: we love bagels, bread-y, chewy, authentic bagels.

So when we discovered that Goldbelly has quietly curated and collected some of the best New York and New Jersey bagel makers on their site, we were pretty excited. You want sesame bagels, poppy seed bagels, everything bagels, cinnamon bagels, kosher bagels, plain bagels? They’ve got that and more, as in cream cheese spread, smoked salmon and lox.

Pricey? Yes, compared to stopping into your favorite bagel shop for a dozen, but it’s a heck of a lot cheaper than a trip to New York. Typically shipping is included so that helps. When the occasion or the craving calls for it, don’t “make do” with “wanna-be” bagels. Order authentic New York bagels, and know it’s worth it!